Exotic meson

In particle physics, exotic mesons are mesons that have quantum numbers not possible in the quark model; some proposals for non-standard quark model mesons could be:

glueballs or gluonium: Glueballs have no valence quarks at all.
tetraquarks: Tetraquarks have two valence quark–antiquark pairs.
hybrid mesons: Hybrid mesons contain a valence quark–antiquark pair and one or more gluons.

All exotic mesons are classed as mesons because they are hadrons and carry zero baryon number. Of these, glueballs must be flavor singlets – that is, must have zero isospin, strangeness, charm, bottomness, and topness. Like all particle states, exotic mesons are specified by the quantum numbers which label representations of the Poincaré symmetry, q.e., by the mass (enclosed in parentheses), and by $J PC$ , where $J$ is the angular momentum, $P$ is the intrinsic parity, and $C$ is the charge conjugation parity; One also often specifies the isospin $I$ of the meson. Typically, every quark model meson comes in SU(3) flavor nonet: an octet and an associated flavor singlet. A glueball shows up as an extra (supernumerary) particle outside the nonet.

In spite of such seemingly simple counting, the assignment of any given state as a glueball, tetraquark, or hybrid remains tentative even today, hence the preference for the more generic term exotic meson. Even when there is agreement that one of several states is one of these non-quark model mesons, the degree of mixing, and the precise assignment is fraught with uncertainties. There is also the considerable experimental labor of assigning quantum numbers to each state and crosschecking them in other experiments. As a result, all assignments outside the quark model are tentative. The remainder of this article outlines the situation as it stood at the end of 2004.

Lattice predictions

Lattice QCD predictions for glueballs are now fairly settled, at least when virtual quarks are neglected. The two lowest states are

0⁺⁺ with mass of 1.611±0.163 GeV/c² and

2⁺⁺ with mass of 2.232±0.310 GeV/c²

The 0⁻⁺ and exotic glueballs such as 0⁻⁻ are all expected to lie above 2 GeV/c². Glueballs are necessarily isoscalar (both for strong isospin, and trivially, weak isospin), with $I = T = 0$ .

The ground state hybrid mesons 0⁻⁺, 1⁻⁺, 1⁻⁻, and 2⁻⁺ all lie a little below 2 GeV/c². The hybrid with exotic quantum numbers 1⁻⁺ is at 1.9±0.2 GeV/c². The best lattice computations to date are made in the quenched approximation, which neglects virtual quarks loops. As a result, these computations miss mixing with meson states.

0⁺⁺ states

The data show five isoscalar resonances: $f$ ₀(500), $f$ ₀(980), $f$ ₀(1370), $f$ ₀(1500), and $f$ ₀(1710). Of these the $f$ ₀(500) is usually identified with the $σ$ of chiral models. The decays and production of $f$ ₀(1710) give strong evidence that it is also a meson.

Glueball candidate

The $f$ ₀(1370) and $f$ ₀(1500) cannot both be a quark model meson, because one is supernumerary. The production of the higher mass state in two photon reactions such as $2γ \to 2π$ or $2γ \to 2K$ reactions is highly suppressed. The decays also give some evidence that one of these could be a glueball.

Tetraquark candidate

The $f$ ₀(980) has been identified by some authors as a tetraquark meson, along with the $I$ = 1 states $a$ ₀(980) and $κ$ ₀(800). Two long-lived (narrow in the jargon of particle spectroscopy) states: the scalar (0⁺⁺) state
D^*±
_sJ(2317) and the vector (1⁺) meson
D^*±
_sJ(2460), observed at CLEO and BaBar, have also been tentatively identified as tetraquark states. However, for these, other explanations are possible.

2⁺⁺ states

Two isoscalar states are definitely identified: $f$ ₂(1270) and the $f$ ₂′(1525). No other states have been consistently identified by all experiments. Hence it is difficult to say more about these states.

1⁻⁺ and other states

The two isovector exotics $π$ ₁(1400) and $π$ ₁(1600) seem to be well established experimentally.^[1]^[2]^[3] A recent coupled-channel analysis has shown these states, which were initially considered separate, are consistent with a single pole. A second exotic state is disfavored.^[4] The assignment of these states as hybrids is favored. Lattice QCD calculations show the lightest $π$ ₁ with 1⁻⁺ quantum numbers has strong overlap with operators featuring gluonic construction.^[5]

The $π$ (1800) 0⁻⁺, $ρ$ (1900) 1⁻⁻ and the $η$ ²(1870) 2⁻⁺ are fairly well identified states, which have been tentatively identified as hybrids by some authors. If this identification is correct, then it is a remarkable agreement with lattice computations, which place several hybrids in this range of masses.

References

^ Alekseev, M.G.; Alexakhin, V.Yu.; Alexandrov, Yu.; Alexeev, G.D.; Amoroso, A.; Austregesilo, A.; et al. (2018). "Observation of a J^PC=1⁻⁺ exotic resonance in diffractive dissociation of 190 GeV/c² π⁻ into π⁻π⁻π⁺". Physical Review Letters. 104 (24): 092003. arXiv:1802.05913. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.104.241803. PMID 20867295. S2CID 24961203.
^ Aghasyan, M.; Alexeev, M.G.; Alexeev, G.D.; Amoroso, A.; Andrieux, V.; Anfimov, N.V.; et al. (2018). "Light isovector resonances in π⁻p → π⁻π⁻π⁺p at 190 GeV/c²". Physical Review D. 98 (9): 241803. arXiv:0910.5842. Bibcode:2018PhRvD..98i2003A. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.98.092003. S2CID 119247683.
^ Adolph, C.; Akhunzyanov, R.; Alexeev, M.G.; Alexeev, G.D.; Amoroso, A.; Andrieux, V.; et al. (2015). "Odd and even partial waves of ηπ⁻ and η′π⁻ in π⁻p → η(′)π⁻p at 191 GeV/c²". Physics Letters B. 740: 303–311. arXiv:1408.4286. doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2014.11.058.
^ Rodas, A.; Pilloni, A.; Albaladejo, M.; Fernández-Ramírez, C.; Jackura, A.; Mathieu, V.; et al. (Joint Physics Analysis Center) (2019). "Determination of the Pole Position of the Lightest Hybrid Meson Candidate". Physical Review Letters. 122 (4): 042002. arXiv:1810.04171. Bibcode:2019PhRvL.122d2002R. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.122.042002. PMID 30768338. S2CID 73455324.
^ Dudek, Jozef J.; Edwards, Robert G.; Guo, Peng; Thomas, Christopher E. (2013). "Toward the excited isoscalar meson spectrum from lattice QCD". Physical Review D. 88 (9): 094505. arXiv:1309.2608. Bibcode:2013PhRvD..88i4505D. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.88.094505. S2CID 62879574.

Exotic meson

Lattice predictions

0⁺⁺ states

Glueball candidate

Tetraquark candidate

2⁺⁺ states

1⁻⁺ and other states

See also

References

Further reading

Lattice predictions

0++ states

Glueball candidate

Tetraquark candidate

2++ states

1−+ and other states

See also

References

Further reading

0⁺⁺ states

2⁺⁺ states

1⁻⁺ and other states